Sugar Bears Pizzeria

Discover delicious, handcrafted pizzas at Sugar Bears Pizzeria in Lancaster, OH. Enjoy our sweet crusts, flavorful subs, garlic bread, lasagna, and chef salads—perfect for satisfying cravings at great prices. Visit us today!

Welcome to Sugar Bears Pizzeria

Taste the Difference.

Sugar Bears Pizzeria
Sugar Bears Pizzeria
Sugar Bears Pizzeria
Sugar Bears Pizzeria

Sugar Bears Pizzeria, located at 147 Cedar Hill Rd, Lancaster, OH, serves up delicious pizzas and more for every taste. This cozy eatery welcomes families, friends, and pizza lovers to indulge in a variety of scrumptious dishes made from fresh ingredients. Countless satisfied customers rave about the sweet sauce and crispy crust, making it a go-to spot for hearty meals. Whether stopping in for a quick bite or enjoying a meal with loved ones, Sugar Bears Pizzeria offers a warm atmosphere where everyone can feel at home. Plus, the friendly staff ensures prompt service, inviting diners to sit back and savor every delicious bite.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

147 Cedar Hill Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130, United States

Phone

+1 740-689-1717

About

The Culinary Story

Sugar Bears Pizzeria
Sugar Bears Pizzeria
Sugar Bears Pizzeria
Sugar Bears Pizzeria

Sugar Bears Pizzeria creates delicious meals that keep customers coming back for more. With its long-standing presence in Lancaster, this pizzeria knows how to cater to local tastes. Each dish features freshness that adds a special touch to your meal. Pizza is truly the star here, with an impressive selection of specialty pies. Signature offerings such as the Mega Topper and Deluxe Pizza will leave your taste buds dancing. The crust has a perfect balance, crispy on the outside and soft within, making each bite satisfying.

Vegetarians can enjoy plenty of options, while meat lovers will find their cravings fulfilled with hearty toppings.

But the menu doesn’t stop at pizza. The pasta dishes deliver warmth for those cozy nights, while the salads provide a refreshing contrast, perfect for balancing out richer fare. Families appreciate the affordable prices, with average meal costs coming in around $12.98, ensuring you can bring the entire troop without breaking the bank.

After a long week, Friday evenings see a rush as locals flock to indulge in their favorite pies.

For those seeking a quieter dining experience, consider visiting on a Tuesday or early afternoon during the week. With shout-outs on social media highlighting delicious dishes like chef salads and gooey garlic bread, Sugar Bears Pizzeria continues to grow its customer base and community presence. Make sure to stop by, and don’t forget to say hi to the friendly staff.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday2-8 PM
  • Wednesday2-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday12-8 PM

Sugar Bears Pizzeria stands out with its extensive menu featuring 52 delectable options. Appetizers like garlic bread and mozzarella sticks kick off the meal perfectly. The true stars are the pizzas, available in various sizes from a personal 7" cheese to an impressive 17" extra-large mega top. Each pie boasts fresh, high-quality ingredients that create flavor-packed slices, sure to delight each guest. Beyond pizza, there's something for everyone, from robust pasta dishes like lasagna to vibrant salads, including the chef salad. Sugar Bears Pizzeria ensures everyone leaves happy, making it a favorite among locals. The casual vibe suits both takeout lovers and those seeking a relaxing dining experience with friends and family.

Sugar Bears Pizzeria

Approaching Sugar Bears Pizzeria, the welcoming exterior instantly catches the eye. Bright signage and a cozy entrance invite customers to step inside. The casual vibe continues within, with warm tones and friendly decor creating a relaxed atmosphere. Outdoor seating is perfect for those sunny days, allowing guests to enjoy their meals while soaking in the local sights and sounds. Inside, the lively chatter of patrons mingles with the tempting aromas wafting from the kitchen, making Sugar Bears a delightful spot for gatherings and celebrations, whether large or small.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Still my favorite pizza, period! I consider myself a pizza connoisseur for sure. My second favorite is an Italian restaurant with true Italian owners up in Dublin. Both have a thin, crispy crust and a sweet sauce but Sugar Bears wins out by a nudge. We had pepperoni pizza, Chef Salad, garlic bread with cheese tonight and it was just as good as I remembered. Everyone has a different opinion especially when it comes to pizza. The employees I spoke with and dealt with were very friendly. We haven't been here for several years now, they were having staffing issues several years back after Covid. Their for a long time their hours were so sporadic and when they were open you couldn't get through. I felt like a kid again in the 80's when you would try to call the radio station to win concert tickets. You know back when you had to camp out outside of Buzzards Nest for a week to get a few seats. Haha! I highly recommend if you like quality ingredients, thin and crispy crust with a sweet sauce you will be a fan too. Can't wait to go back, see you soon Sugar Bears!

B
Bryan W.

Second time getting pizza from Sugar Bears and it was even better than the first..this pizza was slightly crispier and I'm a fan of that. The pizza is thin crust and cut patty style for anyone interested. The garlic bread and sauce is also really good, the sauce reminds me of Pizza Hut from back in the day. I've had the same cashier both times and she has always been really friendly. Definitely going to be going here more in the future.

N
Nick H.

It's been years since I've been here. My schedule never seemed to align to their hours. Finally got to pick up today. Every bit as good as I remembered. Excellent friendly service. Piping hot pizza! And SUPER affordable.

D
Dawn B.

LOVE this pizza! My favorite things are the sauce, pepperoni, and the onions! Only down side is there was no delivery. Other than that, Sugar Bears is one of my top 3 pizza places in Lancaster!

A
A M.

We found this place when we were looking for some good pizza and another local spot had over an hour wait. We had the meatzza pizza and garlic bread with cheese and sauce. Truly one of the top 3 pizzas I have ever had! The pizza had a ton of toppings and came out super hot and fresh. 10/10 recommend!!

S
Stacey B.

One of the best pizza places in town! Always consistent taste! We're late eaters do to sports & dance so they're often closed in the evening when we are craving pizza. I do always try to order during the day when I have a day off of work though! Yum!

A
Andrea R.